Synthesis of existing evidence on longer-term effects of gender-focused land interventions

Publication
Published in: University of Twente and Utrecht University, for LAND-at-scale

A review of long-term impacts of land registration on women’s land rights

Cover of Synthesis of existing evidence on longer-term effects of gender-focused land interventions

Download the complete publication (PDF, 32 pages)

Abstract

Executive summary from the publication

The nexus between land registration interventions, tenure security, and the resulting impacts on gender, particularly women, has diverse contributions in literature. Although land registration is a dominant land intervention tool, it has received criticisms in many studies as not being the golden solution to increased tenure security. In many developing countries, land rights are primarily embedded in complex social arrangements such that formalization per se may not render the universal solution to equal access and tenure security. Over the years, efforts to safeguard women’s land rights in different country contexts through land registration interventions have not yielded the expected change, especially in the longer term. There is ample evidence in literature and project implementation reports worth learning from. This scoping study reviewed existing evidence to identify potential indicators of long-term transformative impacts through land registration interventions on women’s land rights. It was found that there are limited studies on long-term impact assessment of land registration interventions because many projects are evaluated in the short term. Focusing on Sub-Saharan Africa, Latin America, and Asia, the study relied on literature reviews and interviews with experts and practitioners. Among the evidence of transformative impacts in the short term, the results point towards: increased perceived tenure security; increased investment in agriculture; improved socio-economic status and empowerment of women. Some identified threats to the sustainability of transformative impacts include socio-cultural norms and practices, supply-driven interventions, and costly land registration processes. The evidence to-date is scarce and inconclusive. Through the LAND-at-scale program, we aim to contribute to the evidence base on the longer-term gender-transformative effects of land registration interventions. The study uncovers that generally, when it comes to inheritance, laws from many countries aim to provide equal rights and protection for all. But contradictions may exist between statutory laws, religious laws, and customary practices in the protection of women’s inheritance rights. These contradictions must be critically analyzed to address the gaps. Also, different categories of women have diverse land tenure needs and each land registration intervention tool used (individual, joint, or collective), has its pros and cons on women’s tenure security. Thus, it is important not to follow a ‘one size fits all’ approach, but rather conduct efficient baseline studies to align the contextual women’s land needs to the selected interventions tools or strategies, in order to realize the expected transformative impacts. It is recommended that interventions work closely with local stakeholders and empower local champions, and that adequate project funding and technical assistance are provided to ensure the project’s continuity and scalability even after donors have withdrawn their support.

Publication details

Authors
Dora Dadey, Monica Lengoiboni, Ajay Bailey and Wytske Chamberlain
Publisher
University of Twente and Utrecht University, for LAND-at-scale
Date on the report
April 2023
Resource type
Scoping study
Language
English
Extent
32 pages
Geographic focus
Sub-Saharan Africa, Latin America and Asia
Subjects
Women’s land rights, tenure security, land registration, inheritance and long-term impacts
Source note
The Land Portal catalogue dates the record January 2026.

Program: LAND-at-scale.

Related projects: LAND-at-scale Knowledge management: LANDac contribution, LAND-at-scale Knowledge management: International Land Coalition contribution, LAND-at-scale Knowledge management: KIT support to country partners, LAND-at-scale Knowledge management: Land Portal strategy support.

Original publication by Dora Dadey, Monica Lengoiboni, Ajay Bailey and Wytske Chamberlain. Cover reproduced from the first page. Creative Commons Attribution–NonCommercial 4.0. Publisher’s copy. Land Portal source record.

Share